ARTICLE ·

Should You Take Insurance in Blackjack? The Math Says No

Blackjack insurance sounds like protection, but it’s a side bet that loses over time. Here’s the simple math, plus the truth about taking even money.

The dealer turns over an Ace, and the table asks if you want insurance. It sounds like the responsible choice. Who turns down insurance? But in blackjack, the name is the best thing about it. For a player using basic strategy, insurance is a losing bet every time it’s offered.

What insurance actually is

Insurance is a separate side bet that the dealer’s hidden card is worth 10, giving them blackjack. It’s offered when the dealer shows an Ace, before anyone plays their hand.

  • The cost: up to half your original bet.
  • The payout: 2 to 1 if the dealer has blackjack.
  • If the dealer doesn’t have blackjack: you lose the insurance bet, and the hand plays on as usual.

Notice that the bet has nothing to do with your own cards. You’re not protecting your hand. You’re making a new bet on one hidden card.

The math in one minute

A bet that pays 2 to 1 breaks even only if it wins 1 time in 3. So the question is simple: how often is the hidden card a 10, Jack, Queen or King?

A six-deck shoe has 312 cards, and 96 of them are worth 10. With the dealer’s Ace removed, 96 of the remaining 311 cards are worth 10. That’s about 30.9%, which is short of the 33.3% you need.

Here’s what that looks like with a $10 hand and a $5 insurance bet, over 100 times you take it:

  • About 31 wins: 31 × $10 = $310 won
  • About 69 losses: 69 × $5 = $345 lost
  • Result: down about $35 on $500 in insurance bets, a loss of roughly 7%

The number of decks barely matters. The chance is about 31.4% with a single deck and about 30.8% with eight decks. Both fall short of 1 in 3.

“But I have a great hand”

Holding 20 is when insurance feels most tempting, and it’s actually one of the worst times to take it. Your two 10-value cards are no longer in the shoe, so the hidden card is slightly less likely to be a 10. In a six-deck game, the chance drops to about 30.4%.

A great hand doesn’t need rescuing, either. If the dealer has no blackjack, your 20 is in strong shape on its own. If they do, you lose that hand, and the insurance bet only softens the blow at a cost that adds up over time.

What about even money?

If you have blackjack and the dealer shows an Ace, you’ll often hear “even money?” Saying yes pays your hand 1 to 1 right away, before the dealer checks the hidden card. A guaranteed win sounds impossible to refuse, but even money is simply insurance under another name.

Here’s the comparison on a $10 bet in a six-deck game that pays 3 to 2:

  • Take even money: you win $10, every time.
  • Decline: about 31% of the time the dealer also has blackjack and you push, winning $0. About 69% of the time you win $15. That averages about $10.40 per hand.

The gap is small, and you’ll sometimes push and wish you hadn’t. Over many hands, though, declining pays more.

What it costs over a session

Say you bet $10 a hand for 100 hands and play good basic strategy. At a house edge of around 0.5%, you’d expect to lose about $5 on average.

The dealer shows an Ace about 1 hand in 13, or roughly 8 times in those 100 hands. If you insure every one, you add about $40 in insurance bets, and at a loss of around 7% that costs about $3 more. Your expected loss goes from about $5 to about $8, an increase of more than half, from one small habit.

Is insurance ever a good bet?

Yes, but only in one narrow case. A skilled card counter who knows the remaining cards are rich in 10s can tell when the chance rises above 1 in 3. If you aren’t tracking the cards, you have no way of knowing when that happens, so the right answer is always no.

Your session-to-session results will swing either way, and sometimes you’ll decline and watch the dealer flip a 10. That doesn’t make the decision wrong. Strategy doesn’t change the result of any single hand, and no strategy beats the house over time. Like any casino game, set a budget before you start and treat it as entertainment, not income.

Practice in Orbit Casino

Good habits are easiest to build with nothing on the line. Orbit Casino for iPhone and iPad puts 24 games in one free app, including Blackjack, Baccarat, Roulette, Hilo, Craps, Video Poker, six themed slots and 12 Orbit Originals. It’s all play money, which has no cash value, and its Blackjack table offers insurance, so you can practice saying no without any pressure.

Download Orbit Casino on the App Store

Want nothing but blackjack? Try Video Blackjack, our dedicated game. To learn the rest of the decisions, read blackjack basic strategy, explained simply next.

Frequently asked questions

Is insurance in blackjack worth it?

No, unless you’re counting cards. Insurance pays 2 to 1, so it needs to win 1 time in 3 to break even, but the dealer’s hidden card is a 10-value card only about 31% of the time. In a six-deck game, the bet loses about 7% over time.

Should you take even money with a blackjack?

No. Even money is insurance by another name. In a game that pays 3 to 2, declining earns more on average, although you’ll push whenever the dealer also has blackjack.

When does the dealer offer insurance?

Insurance is offered when the dealer’s upcard is an Ace, before players act on their hands. You can usually bet up to half your original wager.

Can insurance ever be a good bet?

Only for a card counter who knows the remaining cards are rich in 10s. Without tracking the cards, you should always decline.

Try Orbit Casino. Built by Atkinson Interactive. Learn more about Orbit Casino →

Download on the App Store

More articles